Exploring Spatial Differences in Income Inequality

This summer, I worked with Professor Dustin Frye on the topic of spatial income inequality in the United States from the 1950’s onwards. Our main goal was to develop a comprehensive data set regarding the topic.

To achieve this goal, we used the County Business Patterns (CBP). CBP is run by the US Census, and is an annual series that provides subnational economic data by industry. This series includes the number of establishments, employment during the week of March 12, first quarter payroll, and annual payroll. We have access to CBP data all the way back to 1953. Within this data, we were interested in the county level data: county by county, industry by industry, how many people worked in that industry, what they were paid, and what the firm size breakdown was for that industry. The CBP data is in a digital form from 1970 onwards, but before then all we have are PDFs of the original books themselves, which isn’t very useful for economic analysis.

To make the pre-1970 data into a useable form, we used an OCR scanner to run an initial sweep of each year’s book. Each year has several thousand pages worth of data, so this step was crucial, as hand entering was not an option. After the data was read by the OCR scanner, we used excel and STATA to format it and write code that would find errors within the data from the scan. We also found more errors by scanning two different versions of each year. From there, we hand collected what was missed from the scan, and combined all of our data into one set, allowing us to examine income patterns from 1953 to the present day. Using this data, we looked then specifically at Dutchess County and explored local changes in industries and income. Since the 1950’s, Dutchess County has undergone an enormous shift, moving away from being a town with the majority of jobs in the manufacturing industry, and towards a more service-based

Prof. Frye and I visiting an abandoned factory in Beacon, NY

job market. We were able to visit old manufacturing sites as well to help investigate this change further.

Defining Childhood, Defining Empire through the Nineteenth-Century Global Transmission of Smallpox Vaccination

From 1798 through the nineteenth century, imperial leaders and the English elite used vaccination as a tool of colonization. Vaccination, unlike public records such as birth and death certificates, gave British military officials the opportunity to track the population in the colonies. As historian Alison Bashford stated in Imperial Hygiene: Critical History of Colonialism, Nationalism and Public Health, “vaccination came to be important as a means for the collection of information through systems of registration and certification of individual infants and children.”[1] What is left untold, however, is how vaccine matter was transported from providence to providence, even from England to the colonies. This summer, I researched how the British used children, mainly native children, to transport and introduce vaccines to India for the health of British children, but also, how it became a colonial, humanitarian campaign to colonize the providence.

This is me looking for Microfiche in the Vassar Library.

By looking at various primary sources such as childrearing guides, medical journals and publications, and newspaper articles from the Times of India, I found that there was a significant disparity between children of different races and classes and how they were discussed in the sources. For example, the literature only discussed vaccination through a white-English perspective. For the English elite, vaccination was essential to the survival of European children in India. It protected them from the alleged filth that surrounded them. As one guidebook put it, European mothers could not be too careful as Indian nurses, or Ayahs, would be accused of exposing children to the plague-stricken streets of India.[2]

Nevertheless, despite the racism that encouraged mothers to limit their children’s interaction with India or its inhabitants, the truth was that children were exposed to the vaccine lymph thanks to native children. At the time, the easiest and most successful form of vaccination was arm-to-arm vaccination. This means that the vaccine lymph, cow-pox, was first injected into the arm of a child, very likely one of native dissent, and puss would be extracted from that child’s pustule and then transmitted to other children. Vaccinifers, or children used for this purpose, would then travel with vaccinators to different provinces to spread the smallpox vaccine throughout India. These children, unlike the elite children were rarely mentioned in the sources, so much of my time consisted of looking for sources that hinted at the use of native children for vaccination.

Image From Campbell, Helen Y. Practical motherhood. Johannesburg: R. L. Esson & Co., 1910.

This research will serve as the basis of a lecture by Professor Lydia Murdoch next fall in Northwestern University discussing childhood and how it can be used to write history.

[1] Alison Bashford, Imperial Hygiene: Critical History of Colonialism, Nationalism and Public Health, (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2014                        [originally published 2003]), 33.

[2]A domestic guide to mothers in India, containing particular instructions on the management of themselves and their children. By a                                     Medical practitioner of several years experience in India. Bombay: American Mission Press, 1848.

 

 

Reframing Drug Crimes in the Age of Mass Incarceration – Alysha McKenzie ‘19 and Professor Eileen Leonard, Sociology

The United States is currently ranked number one globally for incarceration rates per capita, with a rate of 665 prisoners per 100,000 individuals. These numbers may seem disconcerting; however, they’re by no means arbitrary. There are underlying sociological concepts that explain the driving force for this large wave of incarceration, specifically, as it pertains to drug crimes. This summer, I had the opportunity to collaborate with Professor Leonard and work towards completing the manuscript for her new book “Reframing Drug Crimes in the Age of Mass Incarceration.” The manuscript provides a deeper analysis into understanding how drug crimes are framed as well as how victims of drug crimes are criminalized, thus, highlighting the United State’s biased approach to criminalizing drug-related individuals. In the vanguard of current media, certain populations are heavily demonized–as evident by the mass incarceration of Black and Hispanic men, but it is the more harmful, systematic transgressions of pharmaceutical companies and their alarming role in the United States public health crises, that are largely ignored.

Although I assisted Professor Leonard with research for various chapters, my primary responsibility was to research and draft a chapter in the book entitled “The U.S Opioid Crisis.” This chapter examines the current opioid crisis in the U.S. and investigates how pharmaceutical companies, the medical community, the media, and public policy have contributed to the creation of the opioid crisis. This chapter also explores the role that race, class, and geography play into the construction of populations who are humanized for their opioid use, such as white middle-class individuals, and those who are demonized and ignored, like low-income communities of color. Ultimately, this chapter–and the book as a whole–is meant to provide readers with a critical perspective as to how we understand and criminalize drug-related crimes in the United States, as well as how we can work to better address these crimes.

Diversity in Choral Music: Research and Practice

Professor Christine Howlett and Linda Liu ’19

A choir has the potential to honor the face and voices of the world’s people. However, this potential is often only used to serve dominant ideologies of what is choral music and who contributes to it. This project allowed Christine and I to explore how we can develop the choral arts into a practice that will actualize its potential for diversity and inclusivity. Our work included research into the question of “What do diverse and inclusive choirs look like,” as well as leading the Capella Festiva Summer Choral Festival [SCF], a choir camp that serves Poughkeepsie youth, ages 8-18.

The first half of the program was spent preparing and running SCF. My mindset as the first day of SCF approached was to contribute in a way that would last beyond this summer. To do this, I directed games and activities, led discussions on diversity and inclusivity in choir, assisted in sectional work, conducted one of the concert pieces, and performed statistical analyses of the singer’s feedback surveys. Through these actions, I hoped to create a space for the camper’s that was musically and socially fulfilling.

    

Rehearsal with the Treble Choir

A personal highlight of the camp was hearing the camper’s thoughts as to what they believed diversity and inclusivity in choir included. So much pride bloomed within me as I listened to singers as young as ten speak about issues surrounding how gender roles restrict the inclusivity of choir for non-cisgender women, all the way to fundraising suggestions to increase accessibility for choristers with financial difficulties. These discussions, combined with the feedback from the surveys, will allow their voices to improve the future years of SCF.

Spearman’s correlation between age and enjoyment of the songs, a way of learning which pieces resonated with which singers

After the camp’s conclusion, Christine and I continued the research of our central question. This included collecting literature on the subject of diversity and cultural exchange, searching for repertoire and composers that contributed to our mission of diverse choral music, speaking with experts on diversity in choir, and participating in an Engaged Pluralism Initiative workshop with other faculty, administrators, and students. Together, we delved into issues of honoring music from non-classical European tradition, while avoiding the othering and appropriation of such music; issues of critically analyzing social structures that exclude underrepresented groups of singers, and those that could create welcoming spaces for such singers; and a myriad of other issues. This work will lay the foundation for our upcoming symposium on diversity in music.

Although my work this past summer has come to a close, it is clear that this question of diversity and inclusivity in choir extends far beyond the summer, and even beyond the symposium. I am grateful for the way this research has absorbed, and continues to capture, my heart and mind, for a choir’s potential for positive, powerful change deserves the dedication.

The Tatler

Isabel Bielat ’20 and Professor Robert DeMaria

The Tatler, an influential British journal of periodical essays, circulated between 1709 and 1711. Richard Steele founded the journal with influence from satirist Jonathan Swift. With Joseph Addison and other London intellectuals, Steele produced content that included social commentary, literary criticism, and news. Much like modern media, The Tatler wrote for a society that mingled social, intellectual, political, and entertainment concerns.

This summer, under the guidance of Professor Robert DeMaria Jr., I worked on a critical edition of The Tatler, for publication by Cambridge University Press in 2020. This work will conform to editorial standards of copy-text accuracy, and draw from scholarly sources and digital resources to provide commentary that is relevant and useful to 21st-century readers.

While establishing the text of The Tatler, I immersed myself in the language of the era. An important stage of the editorial process was collating the three early printed editions held in Special Collections and annotating their differences, giving preference to the octavo as copy-text. Textual inconsistencies provided insights into authorship, emerging spelling and grammatical conventions, and the journey of the text from contributor to printer. The collation process, begun by previous Ford Scholars, accumulated enough text to begin the historical and literary footnotes.

In addition to experiencing the linguistic conventions of the time, I found it essential to appreciate the historical context of the essays, and to communicate it through footnotes. The Tatler’s connection to historical events was most obvious in its news reports, such as those related to the War of the Spanish Succession. We consulted concurrent reports in the London Gazette, which Steele had edited from 1707 to 1710, and clarified them using scholarly sources. Where The Tatler referred to historical figures by unclear or contested titles, we identified them unambiguously. Other aspects of the text were enhanced by an understanding of the roles played by specific writers, politicians, theatres, and coffeehouses. Annotating such allusions situated the essays in the social and political spheres of 18th-century London, a London that was observing the world as eagerly as it observed itself.

The advertisements that followed each issue of the Tatler interacted with the preceding text in a metatextually innovative way, and provided local economic and historical insights. For the critical edition, we developed protocols to summarize and contextualize advertisements, as through including Short Title Catalog numbers corresponding to the appropriate editions of advertised books.

While preparing footnotes on unusual vocabulary, we found that The Tatler is considered not merely a representational, but a founding text by sources such as Samuel Johnson’s dictionary and the OED. Additionally, The Tatler is rife with references to other works across a variety of genres and eras. From appending modern translations to the Latin and Greek epigraphs to citing literary quotations, editing The Tatler opened a window into its literary world. We hope the critical edition opens windows into The Tatler’s historical and literary world for readers as well.

I sincerely appreciate this opportunity the Ford Scholars program offered me to participate in The Tatler project. I learned from editing the historic text, researching to enhance the text, and preparing books for publication. As I enter my junior year at Vassar, I am looking forward to continuing this project and preparing for future academic research, especially projects that preserve literary and historical resources in ways that make them accessible to other researchers and students.

Tatler 178 in the octavo edition. Image courtesy of Vassar College Archives & Special Collections Library.

Tatler 178 in the folio printing, preceded by the advertisements from Tatler 177. Image courtesy of Vassar College Archives & Special Collections Library.

 

Research in the Lobkowicz Music Collection

This summer I traveled to the Czech Republic with Professor Libin and alumnus Joseph Gusmano to study the Lobkowicz music collection. The Lobkowicz family is a line of Bohemian nobility that dates back to the 14th century. They are known music lovers, especially the seventh Prince Lobkowicz (1772-1816), who spent exorbitant sums of money on performances, scores, and commissions, and was a patron of both Haydn and Beethoven. Our time was divided between cataloguing and cleaning the collection, and assisting Professor Libin with research for her biography of the seventh prince.

Our workplace, the Lobkowicz castle in Nelahozeves

Our first task was to digitalize the catalogue by inspecting each piece of music individually and recording its attributes, such as the title, composer, publisher, date, condition, and more, into a digital cataloguing program. We also cleaned the scores and moved them into new storage boxes. Cataloguing is a time-consuming process that has already been underway for a number of years, but we made substantial progress. This project brought us into contact with a wide variety of scores, both manuscript and printed, ranging from a string quartet arrangement of Haydn’s The Seasons to piano potpourris inspired by popular operas.

Our research on the seventh prince was centered around opera. The prince had a personal opera troupe that traveled with him to put on performances. We examined the parts used by this troupe, in an effort to find information about who was involved, and when and where they performed. This music was full of life, precipitating joyous discoveries; we became well acquainted with the lead singers who routinely wrote their names on their parts, and enjoyed lighthearted sketches made by bored instrumentalists.

The team hard at work studying opera parts

My experience with this project emphasized the importance of musicology in achieving a complete understanding of history. Music holds a wealth of information; it can reveal large-scale abstractions such as societal values, political ideals, and spiritual beliefs, while simultaneously providing an avenue into a personal, intimate dimension. The research we conducted on the Lobkowicz music collection provided invaluable nuance to our understanding of the family, transforming them from one-dimensional names on a page into living, breathing, and feeling human beings.

The Gilded Years: Passing and the Fictions of Identity at Vassar During fin de sičcle Years — Tamar Ballard ’19 and Professor Mia Mask, Film

Anita Hemmings (1897)

Over the past nine weeks, we have been revisiting a chapter of Vassar’s nineteenth century history. We wanted to learn about the institution’s past to better understand its present and its future in hopes of rethinking how elite institutions can recreate themselves as multicultural, cosmopolitan, and inclusive. We began this journey by researching Vassar’s first known African American student: Anita Florence Hemmings.

Matriculating into Vassar in 1893, Hemmings passed as a white woman, in hopes that hiding her racial identity would give her access to one of the most elite academic institutions in the world. Achieving a Vassar education among well-born, elite white women was a coup d’état for an African American woman born to parents of modest means. 

Clip from the Sacramento Daily Record Union (1897)

 However, living as a white woman meant Hemmings had to forsake her African American heritage, an abandonment that would affect the lives of her family for generations. Unfortunately, she was “outed” by her roommate Louise Taylor a few days before their graduation in 1897. Vassar allowed Hemmings to graduate after a series of private meetings between the President, the Board of Trustees, and faculty.

Though Vassar has long since opened its doors to an increasingly diverse group of students over the years, including a shift to coeducation in 1969, there are aspects of Vassar’s turbulent history with inclusion and integration that still permeate the lives of students 121 years after Anita’s graduation.

Students from under-represented communities (i.e., first-generation, low-income, international, transfer and people of color) are helping to recreate Vassar in the twenty-first century. We all have a role to play in eradicating feelings of discomfort felt by some and helping to create a sense of belonging for all. We can begin this journey by looking back at our institutional history.

 For more information, visit the Passing Beyond Passing site!

Autistic Learning in Out-of-School Spaces (Professor Erin McCloskey, Dea Oviedo Vazquez ’20, Zoë Bracken ’19)

During the summer, we examined multiple ways in which autistic individuals learn from and partake in organized activities outside of the traditional classroom setting. These “third spaces” included a Judo Dojo and a music and creative arts program. At these sites we observed and considered the alternative ways in which individuals learned, grew, and managed their behavior, mainly through the pedagogical framework introduced by Paulo Freire. Our goal throughout the project was to learn more about accessible teaching approaches that empower Autistic students and how these may be implemented into mainstream education. Successful approaches to behavior management and learning are promising in creating viable alternative options for Autistic individuals and their communities. They have the capacity to put into question rhetoric regarding traditional approaches that have dominated the field (such as Applied Behavior Analysis) and the monolithic shadows they cast.

 

In our work we: researched potential field sites to explore in the future (theater, equine therapy, and music therapy programs), analyzed visual and auditory data, transcribed interviews and presentations, took field notes, and compiled and annotated relevant scholarship and research. Our work especially focused on the Judo program and the ways in which it provided increased self-confidence, impulse control, relaxation, and socialization in students without compromising their sense of agency and individualism. We considered the ways in which the teaching practices and the nature of this program yielded these results, looking to the narratives of the involved community the Dojo serves. These approaches were rooted in and shaped by community, Autistic voices, mutual respect, sensory stimulation, deep touch, and gentleness. The results and observations of this work will contribute to ongoing research and the development of an upcoming manuscript.

A volunteer black belt guides two students as they practice throws and falls.

The Life of Garbage in Dutchess County – James Boyd ’19 and Dr. Seungsook Moon

Over the course of the past eight weeks, I have been working with Dr. Seungsook Moon of the Sociology Department to further understand the systems of garbage and waste that are inherent to consumer capitalism. This project worked as preparation for Professor Moon’s six-week class of the same name to be taught in the Fall of 2018.

Collection Day in Arlington!

For the first two weeks of this project, I hunkered down in the library to research and discover theoretical texts to understand the processes of waste and garbage. Though many of these texts were not centered around Dutchess County, they helped us to understand how the county fits into the global systems of waste production, collection, management, and trade. The literature review portion of this project has been crucial to the formation of the syllabus for the class in the fall.

Following the theoretical portion of the project, we began to dig through the archives of the Poughkeepsie Journal and the Miscellany News to craft a historical timeline of the local laws around garbage, recycling, and composting throughout Dutchess County, with some comparisons to other local counties (specifically Ulster), as well as a thorough examination of policies on campus.

Simultaneously, I began to create visual representations of the data presented in the “Rethinking Waste” plan, presented by the Dutchess County Division of Solid Waste Management in 2012. This included understanding the composition of the waste produced in Dutchess County, as well as creating visual representations about where garbage and recyclables from the county are transported.

One of the visual representations that I created showing where and how much garbage from Dutchess County is being distributed at various landfills throughout New York State.

The final part of our project included scheduling and conducting interviews with local officials involved in garbage and waste management throughout the county. Though we had some difficulty with this portion of the project, as finding relevant parties who were interested and available took longer than expected, we were able to interview Atticus Lanigan of Zero to Go, an education-based waste management company based in Beacon, and have scheduled further interviews with the Deputy Commissioner of Solid Waste Management for the County, and tours of waste, recycling, and composting facilities in the Mid-Hudson region.

James on a field trip to the DSNY garage in NYC

Conducting research through the Ford Program allowed me to develop a greater knowledge of sociological theory and interest in conducting independent research throughout an extended period of time. As I prepare to write a senior thesis beginning in the fall, I am grateful for the opportunities afforded to me by the Ford Program which have strengthened my research capabilities and nurtured my interest in pursuing academic research further.

Seungjun (Josh) Kim – Research on 2017 Tax Repatriation Holiday

I researched with professor Esteban Argudo and Ningyao Geng about the tax repatriation holiday which is part of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 (TCJA) enacted by President Trump on December 22, 2017. Our main research questions were the following:

■ Looking at differences in Multinational Corporations and Domestic Firms

■ Does the introduction of the Tax Repatriation Act affect the behavior of firms? If so, how?

■ Looking at differences in firms that will repatriate and those that won’t

■ Assess if the proposed one-time tax repatriation of the TCJA reform will lead or not to higher investment, output, wages, and employment

■ Look at how firms use repatriated foreign earnings

However, due to limitations and challenges to data collection, we mainly focused on the first two research questions. We used the CSV and TSV files uploaded at the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) site. The final dataset we got had 10148 unique firms, 45604 rows and 30+ columns (variables).

Previous Literature that performed research on the repatriation tax holiday from U.S. The American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 (AJCA) generally concludes that repatriation had little to no effect on domestic investment, employment, and R&D. Instead, repatriated foreign profits were used to buy back shares and increase the dividends given to their shareholders.

To keep the firms for analysis constant, we kept only the firms that had values for all fiscal years 2013 to 2016 (Because our data for those years matched well with BEA data) and focused on the manufacturing industry which had the most data points.

The following are some findings from exploratory data analysis:

■ Decrease in UFE doesn’t correspond to higher R&D for both domestic firms and MNCs which supports findings from previous literature

■ R&D for MNCs seems to be pretty stable between 3.5%-3.6% level of assets. Repatriation of funds doesn’t really seem to affect R&D behavior of MNCs

■ For both domestic firms and MNCs, liabilities are increasing over time. Liabilities keep increasing regardless of repatriation, so repatriation doesn’t seem to affect liabilities

■ Has the introduction or announcement of the repatriation tax holiday incentive firms to stockpile money overseas? (Hence, the increase in UFE in that period)

■ But increase in foreign income in that period would have also contributed to the increase in UFE.